E. coli O103, one of many extra uncommon Shiga-toxin producing E. coli, sickened sufferers at two Victoria, British Columbia, hospitals final April. The Vancouver Island outbreak is now the topic of a research on meals security for high-risk merchandise ready for susceptible populations.
Primarily based on confirmed E. coli O103 instances reported to the Island Well being infectious illness unit, whole-genome sequencing was used within the case research. The Canada Communicable Illness Report (CCDR) revealed the research in its January 2022 version.
The Victoria outbreak recognized six confirmed E.coli O103 instances, with 67 p.c being feminine and a medium age of 61. All have been inpatients or outpatients on the two hospitals. All consumed uncooked minced celery sandwiches ready by the hospital meals companies.
There was little product testing of celery, and residual E. coli contamination occurred by the mincing course of, and “temperature abuse” on the hospitals is suspected of contributing to the outbreak.
The April 2021 outbreak of E. coli O103 was an uncommon enhance. Earlier E. Coli O103 outbreaks have been linked to clover sprouts, bison meat, floor beef, cured mutton sausages, uncooked milk, and fermented sausages.
Celery beforehand was reported as a automobile for Listeria monocytogenes, norovirus, and E. coli O157:H7, however not O103. The CCDR research goal “is to explain the primary outbreak of non-O157 E coli related to celery in Canada and to determine points of fine security for high-risk merchandise ready for susceptible populations, to cut back the probability of those outbreaks sooner or later.”
The research authors have been from the Public Well being Company of Canada, Island Well being, and the British Columbia Centres for Illness Management.
The report continued, saying:
“All instances had been admitted to or visited two Victoria-area hospitals throughout their publicity interval. Of the six confirmed instances, 4 have been admitted to Hospital A, one was admitted to Hospital B, and one case was not admitted to the hospital however visited the emergency room of Hospital.”
The research discovered no associated instances recognized inside the identical timeframe of the Victoria outbreak nationally in Canada or inside the USA.
Dialogue and discovering
“This investigation resulted in a number of suggestions to enhance meals security of this meals merchandise inside the Island Well being area,” in accordance with the report. “Proof from the epidemiological and meals security investigations assist minced celery because the supply of this outbreak. All six confirmed instances have been uncovered to the suspect supply, and no different product was reported throughout all six confirmed instances, regardless of detailed menus for all inpatients. An outpatient who ate a tuna and celery sandwich solely throughout their emergency room go to to Hospital A, the outlier case added additional assist to celery because the suspect supply.
“This investigation additionally revealed sturdy traceback proof — the minced celery served in Hospital A and Hospital B was supplied by the identical provider; the investigation additionally revealed sturdy hint ahead proof — the provider supplied the minced celery product solely to the 2 hospitals, and nowhere else. As a result of the contaminated product was not obtainable by the point of the investigation, and because of the cleansing procedures at Processor A, neither product samples nor environmental samples have been obtainable for testing. Regardless of the dearth of laboratory proof, the authors consider the sturdy epidemiological, traceback, and hint ahead proof is ample to implicate minced celery on this outbreak.
“The outbreak highlights the danger of uncooked greens supplied to susceptible populations and attracts specific consideration to the danger of mincing throughout processing. Whereas earlier work has documented the potential meals security hazards of fresh-cut produce this outbreak serves to doc the potential dangers posed by mincing, which supplies the chance for small quantities of micro organism remaining on the floor of a product, even after chlorination, to be unfold all through a complete batch. Attribution of the mincing step as problematic on this outbreak situation is additional supported as hint ahead investigation revealed that extra coarsely chopped celery from the identical batch was provided to a large distribution community, unique of Hospital A and Hospital B, with no instances of the outbreak pressure of E. coli O103 related to this product.
“Regardless of offering meals to a inhabitants of roughly 800 inpatients every day, identification of solely six instances throughout Hospital A and Hospital B may probably be defined by a low stage of contamination, which can have induced sickness solely amongst these whose sandwiches have been subjected to temperature abuse. Temperature abuse is a recognized automobile for pathogen propagation and was reported by the hospitals in the course of the investigation follow-up. It’s hypothesized that any contamination current after the mincing step in Processor A was additional propagated by these studies of temperature abuse, ensuing within the diseases reported. A advice was made on the two implicated hospitals so as to add a timestamp to all sandwiches to mark the time the product was taken out of the fridge, to cut back the danger of temperature abuse transferring ahead.
“There are a number of limitations to contemplate within the interpretation of those outbreak knowledge. First, publicity knowledge for celery was not obtainable for the wholesome inhabitants controls to straight evaluate with outbreak instances. Nevertheless, on condition that 100% of confirmed instances had publicity to the suspect supply, and this was the one frequent publicity throughout all six instances, the authors really feel assured within the epidemiological proof for this product. Second, the reporting delay for this outbreak was lengthy, which in flip delayed the outbreak identification and investigation. Reporting delays are influenced by a large number of things, however comorbidities among the many inpatient and outpatient instances on this outbreak might have delayed consideration of an enteric sickness prognosis and thus the requisition of a stool pattern for testing. Third, a number of instances have been lacking onset dates as they may not be interviewed. For these people, their onset date seemingly predated their specimen assortment date, which might additionally affect their publicity interval. This was taken into consideration when decoding the publicity knowledge and analyzing hospital menus. Fourth, there have been no meals samples obtainable to check for the presence of E. coli O103; due to this fact, there was no laboratory knowledge to definitively affirm the supply of this outbreak. Nevertheless, regardless of the dearth of laboratory affirmation, the authors consider the epidemiological proof, the traceback knowledge, and the hint ahead knowledge supplied sturdy assist of the suspect supply. Lastly, it couldn’t be decided the place or how E. coli was launched, as an additional follow-up on the grower in the USA was outdoors the investigative jurisdiction of this outbreak.
“Uncooked greens, corresponding to celery, are a recognized supply of E. coli contamination and current a danger to susceptible populations. Mincing in the course of the processing of uncooked greens, and temperature abuse previous to consumption might present further layers of danger,” in accordance with the report.
“This outbreak resulted in a number of suggestions to cut back the danger of minced celery served in hospitals, together with extra frequent testing on the processor, a overview of the chlorination and mincing course of, and a overview of hospital meals companies practices to mitigate temperature abuse.”
(To enroll in a free subscription to Meals Security Information, click here.)