Publisher’s Platform: Memories of a Naughty and Nice List


I’ve been pondering it has been a while since I dug right into a Naughty or Good listing. Right here is one we at Meals Security Information put collectively (with enter from readers) in 2009. Studying these brings again plenty of recollections, each good and dangerous. Shoot me an e mail at along with your ideas on who must be on this 12 months’s listing.

After a lot thought and consideration, right here was the Meals Security Information Naughty listing for 2009:

NAUGHTY:  Stewart Parnell, President of Peanut Company of America, for asking for almost $1 million from his bankrupt enterprise for his personal legal protection fund after transport peanuts his personal checks confirmed had been contaminated with Salmonella that sickened over 700 and killed a minimum of 9. (See “PCA Executives To Divide $875,000,” Dec 11, 2009)

NAUGHTY:  President Obama for NOT appointing a brand new everlasting U.S. Division of Agriculture Below Secretary for Meals Security. ALSO NAUGHTY: USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack for making excuses about it.  (See “FSIS Remains Leaderless,” Oct. 16, 2009) 

NAUGHTY:  Some uncooked milk, small and sustainable agriculture advocates who confused your complete meals security debate by making and circulating false claims concerning the payments.  It truly is about meals security and isn’t a huge conspiracy by Monsanto to wipe out natural and yard farms!   

NAUGHTY:  FDA’s Workplace of Felony Investigations and the U.S. District Lawyer in Georgia for shifting so slowly with the legal investigations of the Peanut Company of America and its executives, together with Stewart Parnell. (See “One Year Later, Still no Charges for PCA,” Nov 07, 2009)

NAUGHTY:  President Obama and Vice-President Biden for ordering undercooked hamburgers for the Press Corps at a DC restaurant with lower than stellar inspection stories.

NAUGHTY:  Washington State College for eradicating Michael Pollan’s “Omnivore’s Dilemma” from the Widespread Studying Program.

NAUGHTY:  The FDA for caving to political strain and backing down on oyster laws.  (See “Under Pressure, FDA Puts Oyster Policy On Hold,” Nov 14, 2009) 

NAUGHTY:  The Senate for being too sluggish on well being care reform to cross significant–and many years overdue–meals security laws earlier than the Holidays.

NAUGHTY:  Weston A. Worth Basis for extra denial of outbreaks and giving shoppers false details about uncooked milk security.

NAUGHTY:  FDA for its failure to manage ridiculous well being claims like Kellogg’s claiming that Cocoa Krispies are a “Good Selection” as a result of it “helps help your baby’s immunity.”  (See “Do Krispies Boost Kids’ Immune Systems?” Nov 01, 2009) 

NAUGHTY:  J. Patrick Boyle of the American Meat Institute for attempting to dynamite the Senate meals security invoice despite the fact that it doesn’t have something to do with the meat trade.  

NAUGHTY:  State public well being division officers attending the Interstate Shellfish Sanitation Convention in October who put trade income forward of public well being. 

NAUGHTY:  Rep. Charlie Melancon for declaring the demise of 15 folks a 12 months is just not too excessive a worth to pay for a U.S. Senate seat in an oyster rising State. (See “Under Pressure, FDA Puts Oyster Policy On Hold,” Nov 14, 2009) 

NAUGHTY:  Secretary Vilsack and White Home for attempting, within the title of free commerce, to roll over Rep. Rosa DeLauro’s efforts to guarantee that the US doesn’t allow poultry processors from transport uncooked poultry meat from the US to China for processing and transport again to the US on the market till USDA has decided that China’s inspection program is equal to ours. (See “Deal Reached on Poultry Imports,” Sep 27, 2009)  

NAUGHTY:  FDA Commissioner Margaret Hamburg for urging Congress to present the Company authority to scale back the depth of inspections in the event that they don’t get all the cash they ask for.

NAUGHTY:  The FDA employees that retains interesting to shopper advocates, “don’t set us as much as fail,” when shopper advocates push for extra inspection.  They by no means say, “assist us get the legislation and assets we have to shield folks.” 

After a lot thought and consideration, right here was the Meals Security Information Good listing for 2009:

NICE: Sen. Dick Durbin for being the driving pressure behind meals security laws within the Senate and the HELP Committee for passing S. 510 out of committee with bipartisan help. (See “Senate Schedules Markup of S. 510,” Nov 11, 2009)

NICE: Rep. Rosa DeLauro and Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand for being shopper champions and chronic advocates of meals security reform. (See “DeLauro Urges Inquiry Into Beef Testing,” Nov 13, 2009, “DeLauro Calls for Beef Plant Closure,” Dec 10, 2009 and “Gillibrand to Introduce ‘E.coli Eradication’ Bill,” Oct 14, 2009) 

NICE:  Meals & Drug Administration Commissioner Margaret Hamburg for enhancing public entry to info, together with “Warning Letters” and 483 Reviews.  (See “FDA Expands What’s In ‘Warning Letters,’” Sep 17, 2009) 

NICE: Secretary Vilsack and Deputy Secretary Kathleen Merrigan for USDA’s new outreach packages, like “Know your farmer, know your meals.”  (See “USDA Promotes Local Food,” Sep 25, 2009)

NICE: New York Instances author Michael Moss for his Pulitzer-worthy article on the darkish origins of floor beef and the horrible impression of E. coli O157:H7. 

NICE: The fast work of the U.S. Home Vitality and Commerce Committee, whose members labored rapidly and received their arms on incriminating e mail visitors between the PCA executives, who took the Fifth Modification when referred to as to testify.  

NICE:  President Obama for establishing the Meals Security Working Group.

NICE: The general public, for an outpouring of help for WSU’s Widespread Studying Program (hat tip, Meals Democracy Now). 

NICE: Makers of Meals, Inc, who launched the nation to the underside of meals manufacturing, and made a really watchable – if scary – movie about it.

NICE: Michelle Obama, for planting a kitchen backyard on the White Home, and getting children concerned in (very) native meals and for getting a neighborhood DC farmer’s market by way of the purple tape.

NICE:  FDA for getting a responsible plea by Mark McAfee of OPDC to legal costs of misbranding uncooked milk and promoting throughout state strains as “pet meals.”  (See “FDA Attempts to Corral Raw Milk Producer,” Dec 17, 2009) 

NICE:  Marion Nestle for, amongst different issues, her persistent and customary sense critique of how junk meals and soda is marketed to kids.  (See “Q&A: Nestle on Food Safety Politics,” Sep 21, 2009) 

NICE: Mike Taylor and Don Kraemer at FDA for boldly placing public well being forward of Gulf Coast oyster trade income.  (See “FDA Acts to Reduce Raw Oyster Poisoning,” Oct 20, 2009) 

NICE:  Client and public well being teams which have joined with produce growers and meals processors and retailers to help FDA reform laws, making its passage doable.  (See “Victims: ‘We Want Bill Before Holidays’,” Oct 08, 2009)

NICE: Devoted writers whose wonderful articles gave perception and context to meals issues of safety:  Lyndsey Layton of the Washington Put up for her piece on Linda Rivera’s battle with E. coli O157:H7 from cookie dough, Peter Eisler, Elizabeth Weise, and others of USA Right now for his or her reporting on college lunches, and Nick Grube of the Day by day Triplicate for his three-part sequence on Mari Tardiff’s battle to get better from the Campylobacter an infection and ensuing Guillain-Barre Syndrome she received from ingesting uncooked milk.

NICE:  Meals Bloggers – Easy, Good and Tasty, Chilly Reality, Ag and Meals Legislation, Civil Eats, Grist, Weaversway, Chuck Jolley, Meals Politics, Ethicurean, La Vida Locavore, Obamafoodorama, Meals Protect, efoodalert, Fanatic Prepare dinner, Recent Discuss, Middle for a Habitable Future, Meals Legislation, Purchase Protected Eat Effectively and Barf Weblog.

NICE: Invoice Marler and Marler Clark, LLP for his or her beneficiant help of all three Meals Security Information places of work in Seattle, Denver, and Washington, DC to make FSN’s protection of vital meals issues of safety doable, at the same time as conventional media shrink.

These lists had been a compilation of submissions from the Meals Security Information writer, employees, readers, and meals security specialists.

(To join a free subscription to Meals Security Information,click right here)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *